The Assembly Financial Institutions and Insurance Committee voted out a bill that would require parties in arbitration hearings involving claims for personal injury protection (PIP) to be represented by New Jersey-licensed attorneys. The New Jersey State Bar Association supports A5297 (Hutchison), which also carves out an exception for pro se litigants appearing on their own behalf.
Earlier this year, the bill’s prime Senate sponsor, Joseph Lagana, noted concerns that in certain PIP arbitration proceedings where arbitrators were awarded attorney’s fees, paralegals and insurance adjusters have been arguing cases, raising concerns of the unauthorized practice of law. The bill seeks to clarify that only a licensed attorney may argue these arbitration matters.
As amended, the bill further clarifies that this requirement applies only to the actual PIP arbitration hearings and that paralegals and adjusters may continue to work on files prior to the hearing and assist with preparation.
The bill remains pending in the Senate and Assembly for a full vote. If approved, it will take effect 90 days following enactment.
ABC Test Faces Scrutiny in a Pair of Bills Considered by Assembly Committees This Week
The Assembly considered two bills that would declare certain professions independent contractors leading to more questions on the impact on the modified rules promulgated by the New Jersey Department of Labor and Workforce Development (DOL) scheduled to come into effect on Oct. 1.
The Assembly Labor Committee heard testimony on A4735 (Hutchison), which would clarify that amateur sports officials are independent contractors for purposes of the state employment laws. School umpires urged the committee to vote yes on this bill to stem the shortage of school sports officials. Supporters of the bill highlighted the unwieldy rules that would find sports officials employees of a number of entities by virtue of a recent interpretation of the ABC test, which determines the classification of an individual as employee or independent contractor. According to one person who testified, the DOL’s recent determination that they are employees arises from a two-year battle with the DOL on the issue.
John Gallante, president of the New Jersey Umpire Alliance and the Tri State Elite Umpire Association, spoke about the impact of the uncertainty of the classification of umpires on school sports. If A4735 is not enacted, said Gallante, volunteer administrators in schools would be responsible for having to secure umpires and navigate the administrative burdens as employers of umpires. The DOL interpretation would also impose unemployment contributions by schools, causing additional hardships to school sports. “In this situation, the DOL’s approach harms the very individuals and organizations that our labor system is designed to protect,” Gallante said. He also pointed out that New Jersey would be the only state in the country to make these individuals employees.
Later in the week, the Assembly Financial Institutions and Insurance Committee and the Assembly Appropriations Committee considered A1511 (Frieman) , which would clarify the choice of independent contractor status for certain licensed or regulated professionals. It carves out certain professionals from the ABC test so long as they perform services under a written agreement that designates them as independent contractors and they fall within specified categories. Both committees passed the bill with additional amendments that left those in support of the bill with questions about whether the carve out went far enough. The bill’s sponsor pledged to work with insurance stakeholders to clarify the carve out. Others, such as the New Jersey Business and Industry Association, which has created a broader stakeholder group to urge a delay of the Oct. 1 rule amendments, warned that these carve-outs are only the beginning and that other sectors will also have to be carved out because the rules are too broad and cause confusion. The Assembly bill faces a full vote in the Assembly and would need to back to the Senate for another vote on the amendments.
The modified ABC test rules become effective on Oct. 1. Recently, Senate President Nicholas sent a letter to Gov. Mikie Sherrill urging a delay of the implementation of these rules until July 1, 2027.
“In less than five weeks, the New Jersey Department of Labor’s ‘ABC’ test regulations become operative,” Scutari said in his letter to the governor. “Even after modification upon adoption, we continue to hear concerns that they are too broad and will have a severe adverse impact on workers and businesses.”
The Association opposed the modified rules, highlighting concerns that the rules could significantly impact solo or small firms that rely on per diem attorneys and contracted professionals for support, such as paralegals, accountants, and investigators.
A continuing legal education program on the new ABC test rules is scheduled for Sept. 22. To register for the program, click here.